Introduction

The United States is often portrayed as a country deeply rooted in the automobile culture, where public transportation plays a secondary role. This article aims to explore the reasons behind the lack of public transportation in certain states and the context surrounding this issue.

Perception and Demand

One of the common arguments against the need for public transportation is the general perception that people do not want it. Many individuals prefer to live in quiet neighborhoods away from the hustle and bustle of city life and retail areas. They find convenience in personal vehicles, which provide flexibility and personal space. However, it is important to recognize that despite this perception, not all states in the U.S. are devoid of public transportation. In fact, certain sparsely populated areas often lack the practicality of mass transit due to low population density and insignificant travel demands.

The Economics of Public Transportation

Logistically, it makes little economic sense to run public transportation such as buses and trains frequently in areas with minimal population. In regions where bus routes can go days without any riders, the costs associated with operating these services far outweigh the potential benefits. For instance, during my tenure as a bus driver in Tucson, I frequently encountered days where no passengers boarded the vehicle. This raised the question of whether running such services is sustainable and justifiable.

Car Culture and Accessibility

A significant factor contributing to the prevalence of personal vehicles in the U.S. is the car culture. Even those considered economically disadvantaged often have access to personal cars. This widespread ownership of automobiles creates a low demand for public transportation in many areas, making it challenging for these services to become economically viable.

It is noteworthy that there is a higher demand for public transportation in many European cities compared to their American counterparts. While some Americans may not demand such services, there is a significant group of Europeans who advocate for and promote the expansion of public transportation systems in American cities, citing environmental, economic, and social benefits. This disparity in demand can be attributed to varying factors, including cultural differences and historical developments in transportation infrastructure.

The lack of public transportation in some states in the U.S. is a multifaceted issue influenced by economic, cultural, and demographic factors. While the utility of public transportation is undeniable, the logistics and cost-effectiveness of such services in sparsely populated areas need to be carefully considered. As the debate continues, there is a growing recognition of the need to balance the benefits of personal vehicles with the advantages of a more integrated and sustainable transportation network.